Thursday, March 27, 2008

The babbling classes

The always thoughtful Stanley Fish directs a well-placed blow at the inanity of the politics of guilt by association:

This denouncing and renouncing game is simply not serious. It is a media-staged theater, produced not in response to genuine concerns – no one thinks that Obama is unpatriotic or that Clinton is a racist or that McCain is a right-wing bigot – but in response to the needs of a news cycle. First you do the outrage (did you see what X said?), then you put the question to the candidate (do you hereby denounce and renounce?), then you have a debate on the answer (Did he go far enough? Has she shut her husband up?), and then you do endless polls that quickly become the basis of a new round.

Meanwhile, the things the candidates themselves are saying about really important matters – war, the economy, health care, the environment – are put on the back-burner until the side show is over, though the odds are that a new one will start up immediately.

"Not serious" is a phrase that has described politics pretty much since I became politically aware in the mid-1990s. I think the fact that Obama at least tries to maintain some level of intelligence and maturity in the discourse of his campaign is one of the reasons he appeals to me.

No comments: